First Team

Year Player(s)
1955 Bob McManus
1956 Jack McManus
1960 Henry Akervall, John Kosiancic
1962 Henry Akervall, Lou Angotti, Garry Bauman, Jerry Sullivan
1963 Garry Bauman, George Hill
1964 Garry Bauman, Norm Wimmer
1965 Tony Esposito
1966 Tony Esposito, Bruce Riutta
1967 Tony Esposito
1969 Al Karlander
1971 Rob Murray, Morris Trewin
1974 Jim Nahrgang, Mike Zuke
1975 Bob D’Alvise, Jim Warden
1976 George Lyle, Mike Zuke
1981 Tim Watters
1989 Shawn Harrison
1990 Kip Noble
1993 Jamie Ram
1994 Jamie Ram
1998 Andre Savage
2005 Colin Murphy
2015 Tanner Kero, Jamie Phillips
2016 Alex Petan

Second Team

Year Player(s)
1953 Joe deBastiani
1955 Jack McManus
1956 Bob McManus
1957 Tom Kennedy, Jack McManus
1960 Paul Coppo, George Cuculick, Gerald Fabbro
1961 Henry Akervall, Lou Angotti, Bill Rowe, Jerry Sullivan
1962 Gene Rebellato, Elov Seger
1963 Gary Begg, John Ivanitz
1964 George Hill, Scott Watson
1965 Dennis Huculak, Gary Milroy
1966 Wayne Weller, Dennis Huculak
1967 Rick Best, Gary Milroy, Bruce Riutta, Bob Toothill
1968 Al Karlander, Dick Sieradzki
1971 Mike Usitalo
1973 Jim Nahrgang
1974 Rick Quance, Lorne Stamler
1975 Bob Lorimer, Mike Zuke
1979 John Rockwell, Gord Salt
1987 Dave Roach
1988 John Archibald
1991 Kelly Hurd
1993 John Young
1998 Andy Sutton
2004 Chris Conner
2005 Lars Helminen
2015 Alex Petan, Malcolm Gould
2016 Matt Roy, Jamie Phillips

Third Team

Year Player(s)
1997 Andre Savage
2005 Cam Ellsworth
2007 Michael-Lee Teslak
2016 Malcolm Gould, Tyler Heinonen, Shane Hanna

Honorable Mention

Year Player(s)
1953 Bob Monahan, Ray Puro, Harry Taylor
1955 Pete Aubry, Wally Crockatt, Harvey Glover, Cliff Wylie
1956 Pete Aubry, Wally Crockatt, Lorne Holden, Willie Tattersall, Cliff Wylie
1957 Jack Dockeray, Lorne Holden, Bob McManus
1958 George Cuculick, Bill McLay
1960 John Pascht, Jerry Sullivan
1963 Gene Rebellato, Scott Watson
1965 Rick Best, Al Holm, Pete Leiman, Bruce Riutta, Terry Ryan, Wayne Weller
1966 Rick Best, Pete Leiman, Gary Milroy, Colin Patterson, Rick Yeo, Steve Yoshino
1967 Peter Grant, Gary Milroy, Colin Patterson
1968 Ken Desjardine, Bill Hughes, Jim Kryway, Gordon McRae, Ed Rivalin, Brian Watts
1969 Ken Desjardine, John Grisdale, John Haines, Gordon McRae, Rob Murray, Ed Shillington
1970 Ron Amadio, Ken Desjardine, Al McLeod, Rob Murray, Gordon McRae, Ed Shillington, Brian Watts
1972 Gary Crosby, Jim Nahrgang
1973 Darwin Mott, Bill Prentice, Rick Quance, Graham Wise
1974 Bob Lorimer, Jim Warden
1975 Bruce Abbey, Paul Jensen, Steve Jensen, George Lyle, Bill Steele, Stu Younger
1976 Bruce Horsch, Jim Mayer, Jim Murray, Stu Ostlund
1977 Nels Goddard, Dave Joelson, Jeff Wilcox, Warren Young, Stu Younger
1978 Dana Decker, Tim Watters, Nels Goddard, Dennis Hjelmquist, Bruce Horsch, Dave Joelson, Stu Ostlund, John Rockwell
1979 Tim Watters
1980 Rick Boehm, John Haddad, Greg Hay, Jeff Johnston, Dennis Hjelmquist, Mike Lauen, Frank Krieber, Darcy Way
1982 Tony Stiles, Bill Terry
1983 Bill Terry
1984 Bill Terry
1985 Chris Cichocki, Dave Reierson
1986 Dave Reierson, Dave Roach
1988 Shawn Harrison, Kip Noble, Damian Rhodes
1989 Tom Bissett, Kip Noble
1990 Damian Rhodes
1991 John Young, Geoff Sarjeant
1992 Geoff Sarjeant, Darcy Martini, John Young, Darren Brkic
1993 Jim Storm, Layne LeBel
1994 Brent Peterson
2015 Blake Pietila, Shane Hanna