First Team
| Year | Player(s) |
|---|---|
| 1937 | Ed Maki |
| 1951 | Joe deBastiani |
| 1953 | Bob Monahan |
| 1959 | John Kosiancic |
| 1960 | Paul Coppo, George Cuculick |
| 1962 | Henry Akervall, Lou Angotti, Elov Seger, Jerry Sullivan |
| 1963 | Garry Bauman, George Hill |
| 1964 | Garry Bauman |
| 1965 | Tony Esposito |
| 1966 | Tony Esposito, Bruce Riutta |
| 1967 | Rick Best, Tony Esposito, Gary Milroy, Bruce Riutta |
| 1969 | Al Karlander |
| 1971 | Rob Murray, Morris Trewin |
| 1974 | Jim Nahrgang, Mike Zuke |
| 1975 | Bob D’Alvise |
| 1976 | Mike Zuke |
| 1981 | Tim Watters |
| 1993 | Jamie Ram |
| 1994 | Jamie Ram |
| 2015 | Tanner Kero |
| 2023 | Blake Pietila |
Second Team
| Year | Player(s) |
|---|---|
| 1950 | Jim Ruhl |
| 1952 | Joe deBastiani |
| 1955 | Jack McManus |
| 1956 | Jack McManus |
| 1990 | Kip Noble |
| 2005 | Colin Murphy |
| 2022 | Brian Halonen |
Third Team
| Year | Player(s) |
|---|---|
| 1950 | Jack Noblet |
| 2004 | Chris Conner |