First Team
| Year | Players(s) |
|---|---|
| 1955 | Bob McManus |
| 1956 | Jack McManus |
| 1960 | Henry Akervall, John Kosiancic |
| 1962 | Henry Akervall, Lou Angotti, Garry Bauman, Jerry Sullivan |
| 1963 | Garry Bauman, George Hill |
| 1964 | Garry Bauman, Norm Wimmer |
| 1965 | Tony Esposito |
| 1966 | Tony Esposito, Bruce Riutta |
| 1967 | Tony Esposito |
| 1969 | Al Karlander |
| 1971 | Rob Murray, Morris Trewin |
| 1974 | Jim Nahrgang, Mike Zuke |
| 1975 | Bob D’Alvise, Jim Warden |
| 1976 | George Lyle, Mike Zuke |
| 1981 | Tim Watters |
| 1989 | Shawn Harrison |
| 1990 | Kip Noble |
| 1993 | Jamie Ram |
| 1994 | Jamie Ram |
| 1998 | Andre Savage |
| 2005 | Colin Murphy |
| 2015 | Tanner Kero, Jamie Phillips |
| 2016 | Alex Petan |
| 2017 | Matt Roy |
| 2022 | Brian Halonen |
| 2023 | Ryland Mosely, Blake Pietila |
Second Team
| Year | Player(s) |
|---|---|
| 1953 | Joe deBastiani |
| 1955 | Jack McManus |
| 1956 | Bob McManus |
| 1957 | Tom Kennedy, Jack McManus |
| 1960 | Paul Coppo, George Cuculick, Gerald Fabbro |
| 1961 | Henry Akervall, Lou Angotti, Bill Rowe, Jerry Sullivan |
| 1962 | Gene Rebellato, Elov Seger |
| 1963 | Gary Begg, John Ivanitz |
| 1964 | George Hill, Scott Watson |
| 1965 | Dennis Huculak, Gary Milroy |
| 1966 | Wayne Weller, Dennis Huculak |
| 1967 | Rick Best, Gary Milroy, Bruce Riutta, Bob Toothill |
| 1968 | Al Karlander, Dick Sieradzki |
| 1971 | Mike Usitalo |
| 1973 | Jim Nahrgang |
| 1974 | Rick Quance, Lorne Stamler |
| 1975 | Bob Lorimer, Mike Zuke |
| 1979 | John Rockwell, Gord Salt |
| 1987 | Dave Roach |
| 1988 | John Archibald |
| 1991 | Kelly Hurd |
| 1993 | John Young |
| 1998 | Andy Sutton |
| 2004 | Chris Conner |
| 2005 | Lars Helminen |
| 2015 | Alex Petan, Malcolm Gould |
| 2016 | Matt Roy, Jamie Phillips |
| 2017 | Shane Hanna |
| 2021 | Colin Swoyer |
| 2022 | Trenton Bliss, Colin Swoyer, Blake Pietila |
| 2023 | Brett Thorne |
Third Team
| Year | Player(s) |
|---|---|
| 1997 | Andre Savage |
| 2005 | Cam Ellsworth |
| 2007 | Michael-Lee Teslak |
| 2016 | Malcolm Gould, Tyler Heinonen, Shane Hanna |
| 2018 | Mitch Reinke |
| 2020 | Matt Jurusik |
| 2021 | Trenton Bliss |
All-Rookie Team
| Year | Player(s) |
|---|---|
| 1991 | Jamie Ram |
| 1993 | Pat Mikesch, Jason Wright |
| 2013 | Alex Petan |
| 2014 | Shane Hanna |
| 2017 | Mitch Reinke, Angus Redmond |
| 2019 | Brian Halonen |
| 2021 | Arvid Caderoth |
| 2023 | Kyle Kukkonen |
Honorable Mention
| Year | Player(s) |
|---|---|
| 1953 | Bob Monahan, Ray Puro, Harry Taylor |
| 1955 | Pete Aubry, Wally Crockatt, Harvey Glover, Cliff Wylie |
| 1956 | Pete Aubry, Wally Crockatt, Lorne Holden, Willie Tattersall, Cliff Wylie |
| 1957 | Jack Dockeray, Lorne Holden, Bob McManus |
| 1958 | George Cuculick, Bill McLay |
| 1960 | John Pascht, Jerry Sullivan |
| 1963 | Gene Rebellato, Scott Watson |
| 1965 | Rick Best, Al Holm, Pete Leiman, Bruce Riutta, Terry Ryan, Wayne Weller |
| 1966 | Rick Best, Pete Leiman, Gary Milroy, Colin Patterson, Rick Yeo, Steve Yoshino |
| 1967 | Peter Grant, Gary Milroy, Colin Patterson |
| 1968 | Ken Desjardine, Bill Hughes, Jim Kryway, Gordon McRae, Ed Rivalin, Brian Watts |
| 1969 | Ken Desjardine, John Grisdale, John Haines, Gordon McRae, Rob Murray, Ed Shillington |
| 1970 | Ron Amadio, Ken Desjardine, Al McLeod, Rob Murray, Gordon McRae, Ed Shillington, Brian Watts |
| 1972 | Gary Crosby, Jim Nahrgang |
| 1973 | Darwin Mott, Bill Prentice, Rick Quance, Graham Wise |
| 1974 | Bob Lorimer, Jim Warden |
| 1975 | Bruce Abbey, Paul Jensen, Steve Jensen, George Lyle, Bill Steele, Stu Younger |
| 1976 | Bruce Horsch, Jim Mayer, Jim Murray, Stu Ostlund |
| 1977 | Nels Goddard, Dave Joelson, Jeff Wilcox, Warren Young, Stu Younger |
| 1978 | Dana Decker, Tim Watters, Nels Goddard, Dennis Hjelmquist, Bruce Horsch, Dave Joelson, Stu Ostlund, John Rockwell |
| 1979 | Tim Watters |
| 1980 | Rick Boehm, John Haddad, Greg Hay, Jeff Johnston, Dennis Hjelmquist, Mike Lauen, Frank Krieber, Darcy Way |
| 1982 | Tony Stiles, Bill Terry |
| 1983 | Bill Terry |
| 1984 | Bill Terry |
| 1985 | Chris Cichocki, Dave Reierson |
| 1986 | Dave Reierson, Dave Roach |
| 1988 | Shawn Harrison, Kip Noble, Damian Rhodes |
| 1989 | Tom Bissett, Kip Noble |
| 1990 | Damian Rhodes |
| 1991 | John Young, Geoff Sarjeant |
| 1992 | Geoff Sarjeant, Darcy Martini, John Young, Darren Brkic |
| 1993 | Jim Storm, Layne LeBel |
| 1994 | Brent Peterson |
| 2015 | Blake Pietila, Shane Hanna |
Coach of the Year
| Year | Coach |
|---|---|
| 1960 | John MacInnes |
| 1962 | John MacInnes |
| 1966 | John MacInnes |
| 1971 | John MacInnes |
| 1976 | John MacInnes |
| 1988 | Herb Boxer |
| 2007 | Jamie Russell |
| 2012 | Mel Pearson |
| 2016 | Mel Pearson |
| 2023 | Joe Shawhan |